Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Ifrah Mushtaq's avatar

This took me back to my hostel days, to him—to Shaf kaak. I remember standing at the gate, asking, "aapko kahaan jaana hai?" "kuin jaana hai?" "entry kiye bagair nahi jaana," even when he already knew where I was heading. He was always quiet, and I often wondered if life had carved that silence into him, if the weight of unspoken stories had made words feel unnecessary. But as days passed, we, the trio—gathered around him, asking, "aap kabse yahaan hain?" "shuru shuru mein yahaan ka maahol kaisa tha?" And slowly, we realized—he wasn’t a man of few words; he was a man waiting for the right ones. He didn’t choose silence; he simply waited for someone who cared enough to break it. Some people aren’t quiet because they have nothing to say. They’re quiet because no one ever asked in a way that made them want to speak. And you’ve captured that beautifully.

Happy to know someone else saw what was always there.

Expand full comment
Amit Moon's avatar

The brain really does sometimes stores mundane memories from the past which had no serious impact on you as a person.

While reading this, I remembered the time when I stayed with my maternal grandma’s sister’s home one summer. I must be 11-12 at that time and she had 5 children. The youngest was a boy and he was a year younger than me. My young uncle and other older aunts ranging from 13 to 20; we hung out solid for a month. I am reminded of many instances happened at that time. Such raw memories, untouched by your “post that life” experiences are rare and are so refreshing that you don’t want to share it with the world.

Thank you for writing this!

Expand full comment
7 more comments...

No posts